The ESOP Advantage: What It Can Mean for Employees, Employers and Shareholders
What if the next chapter of your company could create value for employees while also giving you a path to transition ownership?
For many privately held companies, an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) can address several important questions at once: How do we retain and motivate good people? How do we continue growing? And how do we transition ownership when the time comes?
An ESOP can be relevant to all three questions. That does not make it a three-for-one solution. An ESOP changes a company’s ownership, finances and retirement benefits, so its value depends on how well those pieces fit the company, its owners and its employees.
ESOPs at a Glance
- Based on 2023 Form 5500 data, the National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO) estimates 6,600 ESOPs covering approximately 15.1 million participants.
- Between 2020 and 2024, the NCEO identified 827 acquisitions by the 1,000 largest ESOP companies, bringing approximately 72,000 new employees into ESOP organizations.
- The NCEO estimated 1,387 acquisitions involving approximately 96,000 employees over the same five-year period. Not every acquired employee became an ESOP participant.
The numbers illustrate the scale of employee ownership, but they do not answer the more important question for an individual company: Is an ESOP the right ownership structure for us?
Employees: Ownership, Growth and Retirement Benefits
One of the most visible advantages of an ESOP is the opportunity for employees to share the financial value they help create. Eligible employees generally do not write a check to purchase their shares. Instead, shares are held in a trust and allocated to participant accounts under the plan.
An ESOP account is tied to the value of employer stock, so the company's financial performance matters. Employee ownership creates opportunity, but it should never be described as risk-free.
Participants become vested over time under the plan’s rules. Distributions are generally taxable when received, although eligible distributions can often be rolled into an IRA or another retirement plan to continue tax deferral. When privately held company stock is distributed, federal law provides protections that allow participants, in applicable circumstances, to require the company to buy those shares at a properly determined value.
Employers: Capital, Continuity and Performance
Employee ownership does not automatically create an ownership culture. Employees need to understand how the business works, how their decisions affect results and where they can make a difference.
Research has found positive relationships between ESOP adoption and productivity. A 2026 study using U.S. Census manufacturing data estimated a 5.6% to 6.7% increase in labor productivity associated with ESOP adoption. The study found stronger results when employee ownership was paired with broad-based performance practices. That is meaningful evidence, not a promise that changing ownership alone changes performance.
An ESOP can play a role in financing a transition. In a leveraged ESOP, the trust borrows money to acquire company shares. The company contributions can be used to repay that debt within applicable tax rules.
Income attributable to S corporation stock held by an ESOP generally is not subject to federal income tax at the ESOP level. For a 100% ESOP-owned S corporation, that can leave additional cash available for debt service and reinvestment. But tax efficiency cannot rescue an overleveraged company or substitute for capable leadership and sound operations.
Journey to an ESOP & Beyond Podcast
Shareholders: Liquidity, Value and Transition
For shareholders of privately held companies, an ESOP can create a buyer for some or all their shares without requiring a sale to an outside buyer. That can provide liquidity while potentially allowing the business to remain independent and preserving elements of its culture, leadership and legacy.
A transaction still has to work for the company after closing. The ESOP’s purchase is subject to a fiduciary process, and seller liquidity should not create an obligation the company cannot reasonably support. The Department of Labor emphasizes that ESOP fiduciaries must act prudently on behalf of participants and the ESOP cannot pay more than fair market value for employer stock.
Federal tax law may allow qualifying shareholders to defer gain on certain sales of eligible privately held C corporation stock to an ESOP when specific requirements are met, including reinvestment in certain qualifying securities. Its availability depends on the facts and should be evaluated with the owner’s tax advisers.
Evaluating the ESOP Advantage
The most useful way to think about an ESOP is not as one strategy producing three automatic wins. It is an ownership structure that can create different kinds of value for employees, the company and selling shareholders when their interests can be responsibly aligned.
The starting point is understanding what the owner wants to accomplish, what the company can responsibly support and what the transition asks of the people who will carry the business forward.
A successful ESOP isn't simply one that closes. It's one that leaves the company, plus its owners and employees, positioned to succeed after it does.
Your Trusted ESOP Advisors
If you’re ready to explore the ESOP advantage, count on our ESOP advisory specialists to guide you every step of the way.